Prompts Are the New Squarespace Plugins

I recently asked SquareKicker Compose to create a Typeform-style contact form on my Squarespace website.

I wanted visitors to move through the form one question at a time, with a progress indicator and the ability to navigate backward.

I gave it one prompt.

Compose built the form directly on my website, using my existing fonts and colors. It even generated controls so I could adjust the details without touching the code.

After experimenting with a few more customizations, I had a thought:

Prompts are the new plugins.

And I started wondering whether someone could build a business selling them.

Because I've been here before.

Meet Compose: AI-Powered Design Inside Squarespace

How I got into selling Squarespace plugins

In 2017, a client paid me $500 to make the product images on their Squarespace website change based on which options a customer selected.

I hired a developer to create the functionality.

Afterward, I asked whether we could license what he'd built to other Squarespace users.

He asked, "Do you mean like a plugin?"

About a week later, we launched our first plugin.

That became the foundation of a business partnership that lasted nearly a decade. Dmytro handled development and technical support while I focused on marketing and distribution.

We identified problems Squarespace users were willing to pay to solve, developed solutions once, and sold them repeatedly.

I didn't know how to write the code, but I got pretty good at recognizing what people would pay for.

So naturally, experimenting with Compose got me thinking.

What would I do if I were starting that business today?

What caught my attention about Compose

AI-generated Squarespace code isn't particularly new anymore.

ChatGPT and Claude can both generate HTML, CSS, and JavaScript for custom layouts and interactions. I even tested Claude on the same Typeform-style contact form and got a functioning result.

What interested me about Compose was the workflow.

SquareKicker built it to work directly inside Squarespace. It understands your site's existing styles and structure, lets you preview customizations on the actual page, and generates controls for adjusting the results.

With Claude, I had to provide more context and handle more of the implementation myself.

Compose produced something that already looked like it belonged on my website.

I've since experimented with navigation menus, hover effects, and other interactions, including a customization for the Squarespace Member Area navigation.

But what really got me thinking about the plugin business was what SquareKicker was already giving away.

A catalog of customizations, complete with prompts

Take a look at SquareKicker's Discover gallery.

You'll find custom Squarespace designs and interactions, complete with starting prompts and instructions for recreating them.

There's a folding image hover effect that makes images fold like paper, an expanding split-screen navigation menu, and dynamic mega menus that pull content from other Squarespace pages and collections.

These are the kinds of customizations we've been developing and selling as plugins for years.

Looking through the gallery, I couldn't help but imagine what an entire marketplace of these customizations might look like.

Could you build a business selling Squarespace prompts?

Say you're a Squarespace designer and you've developed a particularly cool navigation menu for a client using Compose.

You've figured out the right prompt, worked through the issues, and gotten it looking great on desktop and mobile.

What's stopping you from documenting that process and selling it to other designers?

You could create a working demo, provide the prompt and installation instructions, and show a few different ways to adapt the customization.

Someone could specialize in navigation menus. Someone else could build a collection of animations, galleries, or interactive product displays.

If you've been designing Squarespace websites for years, you probably already know what some of these products could be.

Think about all the times a client has asked for something Squarespace doesn't do out of the box.

How many of those requests have you encountered more than once?

Why would someone pay for a prompt?

Especially when SquareKicker is already giving so many away for free?

I remember asking a similar question about plugins.

There was plenty of free Squarespace code available when we started. People could find tutorials, snippets, and workarounds online.

That didn't stop them from buying our plugins.

People are often happy to pay to avoid spending their afternoon figuring something out.

I'd imagine the same principle applies here.

A prompt you've tested across multiple websites, with clear setup instructions, documented variations, and guidance for troubleshooting common issues, could be worth paying for.

Especially if I'm a designer who can put that customization to use on multiple client projects.

The value would be in all the work you've done to make the customization easy for me to reproduce.

Of course, there's a degree of unpredictability with AI that you'd have to account for in a business like this. The same prompt might produce different results on different websites.

Figuring out how to deliver a reasonably consistent experience would be part of developing the product.

Would I still buy a plugin?

Absolutely.

When someone purchased a plugin from us, they were buying functionality that had already been developed, packaged, and tested, with someone responsible for keeping it working.

Customers emailed us about installations, compatibility problems, mobile layouts, and updates. Sometimes Squarespace changed something and a plugin needed to be revised.

Those responsibilities don't disappear because AI generates the code.

If a well-supported plugin already does what I need, I may still prefer to buy it. I'd be especially cautious about relying on generated code for complex functionality involving payments, authentication, or private data.

But if I want a particular hover effect or an unusual navigation interaction, I may not need something engineered to work across thousands of Squarespace websites.

I just need it to work on mine.

What happens to the plugin business?

I haven't tested selling prompts, so I don't know how big the market might be.

But I'm intrigued by what tools like Compose make possible for people who have spent years working with Squarespace.

For most of my time in the plugin business, I'd come across a problem, discuss it with Dmytro, and we'd figure out whether it was worth developing a solution.

Now I can do much more of that experimentation myself.

And so can every Squarespace designer who's accumulated years of firsthand knowledge about what clients want from their websites.

Being able to build something is only one part of creating a successful product. You still have to understand who needs it, what they're willing to pay for, and how to reach them.

The barrier to creating the solution is getting lower. The challenge of finding something people are willing to pay for remains.

And to me, that was always the more interesting part of the business.

Omari Harebin

Omari Harebin started sqspthemes over a decade ago as a live case study on building a business around Squarespace. He’s since helped dozens of plugin developers and designers generate millions of dollars in combined revenue across the ecosystem. He also runs Bigger Budget Projects, which helps web consultants and small agency owners find and win higher-value website contracts.

https://www.omariharebin.com
Previous
Previous

Before You Launch Your Next Squarespace Website, Run This Check

Next
Next

What I Wish I’d Known About Landing Bigger Projects